%20(2).png)
As generative AI (GenAI) emerges as a transformative force in Human Resource Management (HRM), HR leaders are confronted with a proliferation of GenAI readiness assessments. While these assessments are often marketed as essential first steps, our analysis suggests they may be more of a strategic diversion than a necessity. This article challenges the prevailing narrative surrounding GenAI readiness checks and proposes a more nuanced, experimentation-driven approach to GenAI adoption in HR (and other) practices.
Importantly, we argue that in the rapidly evolving field of GenAI, "If you are ready, you are already too late." HR should shift its focus away from generic assessments and toward rapid, targeted experimentation, focusing on value-driven outcomes. The real cost of these assessments isn’t just monetary: it’s the lost time, misplaced priorities, and delayed action.
Large consulting firms have adopted a familiar playbook to promote GenAI readiness assessments for HR departments, tapping into fear and uncertainty to create urgency. Yet, this strategy often falls short in addressing the real challenges of implementing GenAI.
GenAI readiness in HR isn't a universal metric, it’s highly case-specific. GenAI assessments miss these critical nuances, leading to misguided strategies and wasted resources. The focus should be on targeted, use-case-driven readiness. Instead, many of these assessments repackage outdated frameworks, ignoring the dynamic and evolving nature of GenAI. This oversight has costly implications, not just financially, but in terms of misaligned HR strategies and missed opportunities.
Striving for perfection in readiness assessments can be counterproductive. As LinkedIn co-founder Reid Hoffman famously noted, "If you’re not embarrassed by the first version of your product, you’ve launched too late." This is especially true for GenAI in HR. Early, imperfect implementations in areas like resume screening or employee query handling yield invaluable, real-world insights that no theoretical assessment can match. Waiting for perfection only delays progress and stifles innovation.
The financial outlay of these assessments is just the beginning. The real cost lies in diverting critical resources away from immediate HR priorities. Worse, many of these readiness checks repackage traditional consulting methodologies under the GenAI umbrella, misleading HR leaders about the nature of the services they’re purchasing.
Many readiness checks are little more than sales tools designed to sell follow-up projects. While wrapped in the GenAI banner, they often rely on outdated methodologies that fail to reflect the technology's adaptive, learning capabilities. As a result, HR leaders are frequently led astray, paying for strategies that don’t align with the true potential of GenAI.
As a plan is not a strategy in a field as dynamic as GenAI, agility, and action are far more valuable than overly cautious planning. HR leaders should focus on targeted use cases, driving real-world applications rather than relying on broad, generic assessments that fail to capture the true potential of this transformative technology.
Rather than relying on broad readiness assessments, HR organizations should focus on targeted experimentation with GenAI. This approach begins with identifying use cases that align closely with strategic HR goals, such as improving the candidate experience or enhancing personalized learning and development. Creating sandbox environments allows for rapid iteration and learning, enabling HR teams to gather real-world data on GenAI's performance in their specific context.
Remember, if you're not slightly uncomfortable with what you're releasing, you might be moving too slowly. Embrace imperfect early attempts, such as a GenAI-powered chatbot for employee FAQs, as valuable learning opportunities.
While external expertise is often necessary, building strong internal capabilities is crucial for long-term success in GenAI adoption within HRM. HR organizations should focus on three key areas:
1. Talent Development: Upskill existing HR teams through targeted training programs and hands-on experience with GenAI tools for tasks like interview scheduling or performance review analysis. This will create a foundation of in-house expertise and reduce dependence on external consultants over time.
2. Data infrastructure: Beyond just technical capabilities, ensure your HR data infrastructure is built with solid data governance frameworks. This includes managing data quality, security, and compliance, particularly with regulations like GDPR. Prepare for GenAI applications that require sensitive data, such as employee well-being analytics or personalized learning recommendations, by establishing clear protocols for data access, usage, and retention. Implement risk management strategies to safeguard against potential data breaches and privacy violations, ensuring your organization maintains trust and avoids costly compliance issues.
3. Innovation culture: Foster an environment encouraging experimentation, learning from failures, and rapid iteration in HR tech adoption. This cultural shift is essential for staying agile in the fast-moving field of GenAI for HRM.
By prioritizing these areas, HR organizations can develop the internal competencies needed to drive and sustain GenAI initiatives. However, it's crucial to balance capability building with action. Don't wait until you feel fully prepared, start implementing GenAI in low-risk HR processes and learn in real-time.
Most HR organizations will need to engage external experts during their GenAI journey, particularly in the initial stages of implementing complex applications like AI-driven succession planning or sentiment analysis. The key to success lies in effectively steering and controlling these external capabilities. This requires developing "informed buyer" capabilities within the HR organization.
An informed buyer in HR possesses enough understanding of GenAI to make strategic decisions, set clear objectives, and critically evaluate the work of external consultants:
1. Develop a core HR tech team with a strong foundation in GenAI as applied to HR.
2. Establish clear governance structures for AI initiatives in HR processes.
3. Create a framework for evaluating and selecting external partners for HR tech implementations.
4. Implement robust project management and oversight processes for GenAI in HR initiatives.
5. Foster knowledge transfer from external experts to internal HR and IT teams.
By balancing internal capability building with strategic use of external expertise, HR organizations can navigate the complexities of GenAI adoption more effectively, benefiting from cutting-edge knowledge while gradually developing in-house expertise in HR tech.
Here are key recommendations for HR leaders embarking on their GenAI journey:
1. Resist the ideas surrounding GenAI readiness checks and instead focus on practical applications that can immediately enhance your HR processes.
2. Identify specific, strategic use cases for GenAI in your HR operations, such as improving candidate sourcing or enhancing employee onboarding, and start experimenting with these applications quickly.
3. Embrace imperfect early attempts at GenAI implementation in HR as valuable learning opportunities. For instance, a less-than-perfect AI-driven resume screening tool can still provide insights for improvement.
4. Build internal HR tech capabilities while effectively managing external expertise. This dual approach ensures you're developing long-term competencies while benefiting from immediate external knowledge.
5. Foster a culture within your HR team that values rapid iteration and learning from failure in tech adoption. This mindset is crucial for successful GenAI implementation in HRM.
6. Remember that in the fast-paced world of HR tech, being "ready" often means you're already behind. Act now to implement GenAI in your HR processes, learn fast from real-world applications, and iterate based on outcomes.
By focusing on targeted experimentation, building internal capabilities, and taking a measured yet timely approach to adoption, HR organizations can navigate the complexities of GenAI more effectively. This strategy not only mitigates risks associated with premature large-scale adoption but also positions HR teams to leverage GenAI's transformative power in alignment with their unique talent management objectives and organizational context.
In the rapidly evolving world of GenAI for HRM, the greatest risk is not imperfect action but inaction. Start your GenAI journey in HR now, even if you don't feel fully prepared. The insights gained from early, real-world implementations will prove far more valuable than any generic readiness assessment.
